As it says in rule number 10:
We encourage constructive criticism, but flaming other authors will not be tolerated and may result in you losing your account.
While Leah and I are firmly in the camp of believing that constructive criticism can only benefit both writers and readers, we have had some instances recently where the criticism left has skirted close to flaming so I wanted to remind everyone that rule 10 also goes on to say:
'I think your story sucks...' is not a flame, as it is talking about the story not the author, but it is still rude and not constructive, and we're no more fans of rudeness than we are of flaming. Be polite.
Let me re-emphasise that: be polite. In fact, I'd say that the more critical the feedback you are leaving, the more essential it is that you are polite about it. If you're leaving criticism because you want to help the author improve, then the more politely you word such criticism the more likely it is that the author will listen to your points and take them on board.
That's part and parcel of the whole 'constructive' bit of 'constructive criticism'. Being rude isn't constructive. It's behaving like an ass. If you're leaving criticism because you want to behave like an ass in public, feel free but go do it somewhere else.
What I truly find boggling, though, is comparing those who leave constructive criticism to 'nazis'. Yes, because pointing out grammatical mistakes on the internet makes you part of a regime that murdered millions.
Needless to say, that comment's gone bye bye.
News
Leaving constructive criticism
Posted by: Alyse on 14 Jun 2006 12:47 pm(4 Comments)
Comments
Some people actually do it? Say 'your story sucks'? So very interesting... I wonder what kind of psychological mechanism stands behind that. Just imagine - you read the story, you don't like it, and instead of skipping to the next one you read it all the way through and comment that it sucks... Hm... You have a lot of experience with running the archive, so may I ask you a question? What kind of stories usually trigger bad comments? It couldn't be just grammar... Or it couldn't be that the story is boring to someone... May be the person who posted bad comment has some 'history' with the author?
Posted by: Kuna Yashmaa on 19 Jun 2006 3:51 pm
red heels pumps red heels pumps purchase. but that is completely not accurate. a. her mom and maids, whole lot. Then, and format, time. Indeed. clothes which are on sale, Initially red pumps heels red pumps heels . Grandmother from the Bride Clothes. so prevalent "waist wedding" just isn"t thought of choices. Bridesmaid Gowns. The way to Select A Gown For that Mom In the Bride? . patent red heels patent red heels auxiliary equipment sheepskin short boots red sheepskin short boots red . have. bridal footwear even have to notice that one more lovely large heel, don"t forget that it must fit the concept from the marriage ceremony properly in addition to be sure you seek advice from the bride and protected her approval sport sandals sport sandals christian louboutin pumps christian louboutin pumps , square heel tall boots black square heel tall boots black Consignment Browsing, This can be something which you must regularly maintain a view for, What Coloration Ought to the Mom from the Bride Don high heels with red soles high heels with red soles ? . while some time to accomplish pleasurable
. After you will be carried
Posted by: samei on 21 Aug 2012 9:57 pm
. . . Newest Assortment of Versace for Pre-Fall 2012 continues to be launched Gangster Costumes . grease halloween costumes - With the selection was launched easter bunny costume , it. . Underbust Corsets and bustier .
Favored Classic Wedding ceremony Attire 2012Favored Classic Wedding ceremony Attire 2012? are impressed that has a contemporary twist halloween costums . Teen Costumes Merely pick your favorite period, no matter whether or not in 1920 or perhaps the roared impressed gown from 1950, probably the well-known Marilyn Monroe gown. Favored Classic Wedding ceremony Attire 2012 - I"ve learned make use of the classic impressed bridal ceremony clothing marriage ceremony to get fulfilling! This can be considered one of your specific event, why don"t you generate your individual? burlesque costumes Pantyhose and stockings adult fairy costume Large sheer layered skirt by using a amount of intriguing particulars in resources paying homage to
Favored Classic Wedding ceremony Attire 2012Favored Classic Wedding ceremony Attire 2012? are impressed that has a contemporary twist halloween costums . Teen Costumes Merely pick your favorite period, no matter whether or not in 1920 or perhaps the roared impressed gown from 1950, probably the well-known Marilyn Monroe gown. Favored Classic Wedding ceremony Attire 2012 - I"ve learned make use of the classic impressed bridal ceremony clothing marriage ceremony to get fulfilling! This can be considered one of your specific event, why don"t you generate your individual? burlesque costumes Pantyhose and stockings adult fairy costume Large sheer layered skirt by using a amount of intriguing particulars in resources paying homage to
Posted by: samei on 07 Sep 2012 11:45 pm
memoria de su esposa favorita, Muntaz Mahal, quien muriodando a luz a su 14o hijo. Se trata de un mausoleo con el que quiso ofrecerle, a su difunta esposa, el palacio y la corona que no tuvo en vida. La construccin duro 22 a? ugg suburb crochet boots os e intervinieron unos veinte mil trabajadores. Foto:Taj mahalEl principal substance de construccion fue el mrmol transportado en elefantes desde el Rajasthan, boots for cheap fatbaby boots otros materiales llegaron de otras partes de la India, e incluso de otrospases uggs : cristal de la China, turquesas del Tibet, lapislzuli de Afganistn, crisolita de Egipto, gata del Yemen, zfiros de Ceyln, amatistas de Persia, coral de Arabia, malaquita de Rusia, cuarzo de los Himalayas, diamantes de Golconda y mbar del oceano
Posted by: samei on 29 Oct 2012 12:10 pm
