Penname: cookiemom6067 [Contact]
Real name: Polly McCall Member Since: 05 Mar 2008
Membership status: Member
45yo mom of 3, married, voracious reader, love mcshep slash
Reviews by cookiemom6067
[ - ]

Summary: Five years after Atlantis, John and Rodney meet someone interesting. No spoilers, suspense plot element to follow.

Categories: Threesomes and Moresomes > All Varieties
Characters: John Sheppard, Original Character, Rodney McKay
Genres: Drama, Established Relationship, First Time, Romance
Warnings: Adult themes
Chapters: 16 [Table of Contents]
Series: None

Word count: 55760; Completed: Yes
Updated: 09 Nov 2006; Published: 07 Oct 2006
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
24 Apr 2008
I'm in the middle of reading this through for the second time in 2 days. I stumbled on it looking for a different story with the same title, and I'm so glad I did. You did a really nice job with Catherine - fandom can be a hyper-critical place for an orignal character, particularly for one getting in the middle of a popular pairing like John/Rodney. Kudos for writing a character that McSheppers like me can really like. Even MORE kudos for having Catherine take care of the rapist herself, instead of being a damsel in distress. As a mother of a daughter, I appreciate any strong female characters I find. I also really liked her integrity about not getting in the middle of their relationship uninvited and for understanding (until things changed) that she did not have a claim on John. I also really appreciated that Catherine so thoroughly owned her own sexuality and had standards for men that wanted to share her bed. The only bit that did not "ring" for me was the supremely short refractory periods evident for John and Rodney, but that's really just a quibble.

Author's Response: I have a daughter, too. Damsels in distress really bug me, too. And as for our intrepid heroes, well, they are supermen, aren\'t they? Thanks so much for taking time to read and write a review. I\'m sorry it\'s taken so long to say thanks, but real life has been much busier than I like for the past few months. Thanks again!
Chapter 1: One
Rising Above by Susan [NC-17]
[ - ]

Summary: Evil!Sheppard in a parallel universe. Poor Dr. McKay with a family to feed.

Dr. Rodney McKay must balance his family life with his passionate and yet cold commander at Stargate Command, Colonel John Sheppard.

Het McKay/Brown and McKay/Carter. Non-consensual Sheppard/McKay, Lorne/Chuck, and mention of non-consensual Kowalski/Other male, Jackson/Other female, and O'Neill/Carter.

Updated: 12 Jul 2012; Published: 15 Nov 2006
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
12 Jan 2009
WOW, Susan - great chapter. I love where you're taking John and Rodney right now.

Author's Response: Thanks cookiemom, I do look forward to hearing from you. Hope RL doesn\'t keep bothering you so much!
Chapter 27: Chapter 26
[ - ]

Summary: Festering wounds should not be ignored. Sequel to "Gaining momentum".

Updated: 12 May 2007; Published: 12 May 2007
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
31 Mar 2008
this series is just wonderful. I believe it is the best and most honest and believable "BDSM lifestyle" piece I have ever read. You are an excellent and thoughtful writer and I appreciate your willingness to share what you have written with us.

Author's Response: Thank you very much!
Chapter 2: Part 2
[ - ]

Summary: Caldwell has something Sheppard needs, but Sheppard has to be willing to take it.
This is a Caldwell Sheppard story folks warts and all.

Categories: Slash Pairings > Sheppard/Other
Characters: John Sheppard, Rodney McKay, Steven Caldwell
Genres: Angst, First Time, Friendship, Pre-slash
Warnings: Adult themes
Chapters: 8 [Table of Contents]
Series: None

Word count: 26155; Completed: No
Updated: 16 Nov 2008; Published: 21 Oct 2007
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
19 Apr 2008
oh my f'ing god. This is so incredibly hot.

Not to mention fascinating and original.

Can't wait until you post again.

Author's Response: LOL I sent you a little email then thought to myself...\'self\' your email will likely end ub in her spam files :) so I thought I would say thanks for your kind feedback and that part seven is at just scroll down and you\'ll find it. \r\nHuggles ~H~
Chapter 6: Chapter 6
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
12 Sep 2008
I'm curious, given that you list this as McShep - is Rodney's name on the list?

Author's Response: Actually no, my beta who is one of the list moms who posted my fic listed it as a McShep.
Chapter 4: Chapter 4
[ - ]

Summary: "It was awful and wonderful and kinky and dirty, and best of all, they were doing this together." Rodney never thought that he could trust anyone with his most guarded secrets. He was wrong.

Categories: Slash Pairings > McKay/Sheppard
Characters: John Sheppard, Rodney McKay
Genres: Drama, Hurt Comfort, Romance
Warnings: May squick
Chapters: 1 [Table of Contents]
Series: None

Word count: 9547; Completed: Yes
Updated: 05 Nov 2007; Published: 05 Nov 2007
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
07 Aug 2008
This is my favorite short "kink" story. It is so well done and illustrates the appeal so perfectly. Guh! Just SOOOO hot.
Chapter 1: Chapter 1
E-mail Tag by Fia Reynne [PG-13]
[ - ]

Summary: A story told through e-mail; After the events of "Miller's Crossing," Jeannie asks Rodney about Katie Brown and learns the truth behind the lack of progress in that particular relationship. From John, when Rodney shunts her off onto him.

Categories: Slash Pairings > McKay/Sheppard
Characters: John Sheppard, Other, Rodney McKay
Genres: Episode Related, Established Relationship
Warnings: None
Chapters: 1 [Table of Contents]
Series: None

Word count: 1645; Completed: Yes
Updated: 02 Dec 2007; Published: 02 Dec 2007
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
11 May 2008
I really liked this - good job.
Chapter 1: Chapter 1
[ - ]

Summary: A what-if fic speculating on how events would have unfolded if Kavanagh, instead of McKay, had been the last occupant of the alien being Sheppard picked up on that planet in "Doppelganger". It had to happen in some reality, right? Includes an an explanation for his snarkiness and general bad attitude.

I am SO bummed about SGA's cancellation, I suppose this means we won't see Kav again. *weeps*

Categories: General
Characters: John Sheppard, Other, Rodney McKay, Ronon Dex, Teyla Emmagan
Genres: Angst, Character Study, Hurt Comfort
Warnings: Adult themes, May squick, Non-consensual
Chapters: 33 [Table of Contents]
Series: None

Word count: 29570; Completed: Yes
Updated: 04 Mar 2010; Published: 22 Aug 2008
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
15 Jan 2009
You've used "Captain" Carter twice - uh, Colonel?

This has been very interesting so far.

Author's Response: Heh. Yeah. See the appended note. I\'m surprised that\'s all I got wrong, if it is. My head was spinning pretty bad from being woken up by the screaming angry drunk maniac downstairs. \r\n\r\nThanks for the heads-up! =)
Chapter 12: Chapter 12
[ - ]

Summary: When John suddenly loses Rodney he finds it an unacceptable loss, but later someone appears who changes everything.
Deathfic but only kind of.

Updated: 14 Feb 2009; Published: 29 Nov 2008
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
08 Jan 2009
this is so devastatingly sad - you really choked me up and made me cry!

Author's Response: Thank you. Hopefully you\'ll like the next part too. :o)
Chapter 7: Chapter 7
Blessed by Mithreon [NC-17]
[ - ]

Summary: John never interrupts Rodney's lesson. AU sequel to When push comes to shove

Warnings aka Read at your own risk: There are very many sick things – incredibly sick things – in this story. I assure you, this *will* squick. Just assume it will be way too much for you and you'll be on the safe side.

Categories: Slash Pairings > McKay/Other
Characters: Rodney McKay
Genres: Established Relationship, Series
Warnings: Adult themes, May squick
Chapters: 1 [Table of Contents]
Series: When push comes to shove

Word count: 7490; Completed: Yes
Updated: 17 Feb 2009; Published: 17 Feb 2009
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
03 Mar 2009
this is SO SAD!!!! I liked it much better when John found out and made Rodney feel loved, instead of disgusting. I do always enjoy your writing, though.

Author's Response: Thanks!
Chapter 1: Blessed
[ - ]

Summary: John and Rodney have only ever exchanged fond glances and corny jokes, but after they inadvertently activate an Ancient device, the men will encounter a dark world and an even darker John Sheppard. But does this evil John Sheppard have a softer side? Readers are guaranteed to cry or their money back!

Updated: 24 Apr 2009; Published: 19 Mar 2009
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
15 Apr 2009
OO - good beginning!!!!

I love Evil!Sheppard stories, as Susan well knows!
Chapter 2: 2
[ - ]

Summary: A lot of things come together to make Rodney go a little weird. Pseudo-crossover with First Monday, no outside knowledge required. John/Julian Lodge.

Categories: Slash Pairings > Sheppard/Other, Crossovers > Slash Pairings, Slash Pairings > McKay/Sheppard
Characters: John Sheppard, Other, Rodney McKay
Genres: First Time, Humour, Pre-relationship, PWP - Plot, What Plot?
Warnings: Adult themes
Chapters: 1 [Table of Contents]
Series: None

Word count: 1177; Completed: Yes
Updated: 20 Apr 2009; Published: 10 Apr 2009
Reviewer: cookiemom6067 (Signed)
21 Apr 2009
I love this!!!! The last sentence, in conjunction with the paragraph about Sheppard not minding if Rodney was fantasizing about him was absolutely brilliant!!!! Just great.
Chapter 1: Chapter 1